The 2026 SEO audit: 40 checks that find the traffic you are leaving behind
Run a full SEO audit in a day: crawling, indexing, Core Web Vitals, on-page, content gaps, links and AI visibility, with a free tool for every step.

Short answer: a useful SEO audit answers four questions in order. Can search engines crawl and index your important pages? Do those pages load fast and work well on mobile? Does each page clearly match what people search for? And do other sites, and AI tools, trust you enough to recommend you? The 40 checks below work through those questions using mostly free tools, and finish with a prioritised list of fixes.
An audit is only valuable if it leads to action. Resist the temptation to produce a 90-page report. The goal is a short list of fixes ranked by impact and effort.
What you need before you start
- Access to Google Search Console for your domain
- Access to GA4 or your analytics tool
- A crawler, such as Screaming Frog (free up to 500 URLs) or a similar tool
- PageSpeed Insights and Google’s Rich Results Test
- A spreadsheet to log issues, affected URLs, impact and effort
Google’s SEO Starter Guide is a good neutral reference for many of the checks below.
Part 1: crawling and indexing (checks 1 to 10)
If search engines cannot find or index a page, nothing else matters. See crawling and indexing for background.
- Robots.txt. Open yourdomain.com/robots.txt. Make sure important sections are not blocked and that it links to your sitemap. See robots.txt.
- XML sitemap. Check it exists, is submitted in Search Console and contains only canonical, indexable URLs that return a 200 status. See XML sitemap.
- Page indexing report. In Search Console, review why pages are not indexed. Focus on important pages listed as ‘Crawled, currently not indexed’ or ‘Discovered, currently not indexed’.
- Noindex tags. Crawl the site and list every page with a noindex directive. Confirm each one is intentional.
- Canonical tags. Check that each indexable page has a self-referencing canonical URL and that canonicals do not point to redirected or broken pages.
- Status codes. List all URLs returning 4xx and 5xx status codes. Fix broken internal links and server errors.
- Redirects. Find redirect chains and loops, and update internal links to point directly to final URLs.
- HTTPS. Confirm every page loads over HTTPS, with HTTP versions redirecting, and no mixed content warnings.
- Duplicate versions. Check that www and non-www, and trailing slash variations, resolve to one version.
- Orphan pages. Compare your sitemap and analytics with crawl data to find orphan pages with no internal links.
Part 2: speed and experience (checks 11 to 17)
- Core Web Vitals report. In Search Console, note which URL groups fail Core Web Vitals on mobile and desktop.
- LCP. Test key templates in PageSpeed Insights. If LCP is over 2.5 seconds, check hero images and server response.
- INP. If INP is over 200 milliseconds, look at heavy JavaScript and third-party scripts.
- CLS. If CLS is over 0.1, reserve space for images, embeds and banners.
- Mobile usability. Browse key pages on a real phone. Check text size, tap targets, menus and forms. Google uses mobile-first indexing.
- Images. Check that images are compressed, use modern formats, have dimensions set and include alt text.
- Accessibility basics. Check heading order, colour contrast, keyboard navigation and form labels. The W3C WCAG overview explains the standard.
Part 3: on-page and content (checks 18 to 28)
- Titles. Every indexable page should have a unique, descriptive meta title. Flag missing, duplicate and truncated titles.
- Meta descriptions. Check for missing and duplicate meta descriptions on important pages.
- H1s. Each page should have one clear H1 matching its topic.
- Search intent. For your top 20 target queries, compare your page with the top results. Does your page type and format match the search intent?
- Answer-first structure. Do key pages answer the main question in the first paragraph? See answer-first content.
- Thin pages. List pages with very little unique content or no traffic. Decide whether to improve, merge or remove them. See thin content.
- Cannibalisation. Find queries where several of your pages compete. See keyword cannibalisation.
- Content decay. Compare clicks year over year in Search Console to find pages losing traffic. See content decay.
- Content gaps. List important topics your customers ask about that you have no page for.
- Internal linking. Check that important pages receive links from relevant pages, with descriptive anchor text. See internal linking.
- E-E-A-T signals. Check for author information, About and Contact pages, clear sourcing and evidence of real experience. See E-E-A-T.
Part 4: structured data (checks 29 to 32)
- Organization schema. Check your home or About page for Organization markup with name, logo and official profiles.
- Page-type schema. Check that articles, products, local business pages, breadcrumbs and FAQs use the right schema markup.
- Validation. Run key templates through the Rich Results Test and the Schema Markup Validator. Fix errors.
- Search Console enhancements. Review the rich result reports for warnings and errors.
Part 5: authority and links (checks 33 to 36)
- Backlink profile. Use Search Console’s Links report or an SEO tool to see who links to you and which pages earn links. See backlinks.
- Broken backlinks. Find external links pointing to pages that now return 404, and redirect them to the best replacement.
- Competitor gap. Compare the sites linking to competitors but not you. These are outreach opportunities.
- Brand consistency. Check that your name, address and description are consistent on directories and profiles. See NAP consistency.
Part 6: AI search visibility (checks 37 to 40)
- AI crawler access. Check robots.txt and any firewall rules to confirm you are not unintentionally blocking AI search crawlers. See AI crawler.
- llms.txt. Consider adding an llms.txt file pointing to your key pages.
- Prompt test. Run 20 to 30 buyer prompts through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Mode, and record whether you are cited. See citation share.
- AI referrals. Check GA4 for visits from AI tools and note which pages they land on.
Turning findings into a plan
Score each issue on two scales from one to three: impact (how much traffic or revenue it affects) and effort (how hard it is to fix). Then sort:
| Priority | Impact | Effort | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do now | High | Low | Remove accidental noindex, fix robots.txt, update titles on top pages |
| Plan next | High | High | Template speed fixes, content consolidation, new topic clusters |
| Quick wins | Low | Low | Fix broken internal links, add missing alt text |
| Later | Low | High | Minor schema enhancements on low-traffic pages |
Share a one-page summary with the top ten actions, owners and dates. Then re-run the critical checks monthly.
A worked example
A regional accountancy firm’s traffic had been flat for two years. The audit found that a staging-site setting had left its services section noindexed, its blog had 40 short posts competing for the same three queries and its home page took five seconds to load on mobile due to an uncompressed video.
Removing the noindex, consolidating the blog posts into four strong guides with 301 redirects and replacing the video with an optimised image took two weeks. Organic enquiries rose by more than half over the next quarter.
Common audit mistakes
- Auditing everything equally. A broken link on a page with no traffic matters far less than a noindex tag on your best service page. Weight every issue by the traffic and revenue of the pages it affects.
- Trusting tool scores blindly. Automated ‘health scores’ flag many issues that do not matter. Use them to find problems, then apply judgement.
- Ignoring templates. Most technical issues come from templates. Fixing one template can fix thousands of pages at once, so always ask which template an issue comes from.
- Skipping the before-and-after. Record baseline traffic, rankings and Core Web Vitals before you start fixing, so you can show what changed and learn what worked.
- Never re-checking. Sites drift. New plugins, content and campaigns introduce new problems, which is why a monthly mini-audit of the critical checks pays for itself.
How long each part takes
For a site of a few hundred pages, a focused audit usually takes a day. Crawling and indexing checks take around two hours, speed and experience one hour, on-page and content two to three hours, structured data and links one hour each, and AI visibility checks about an hour. Larger sites take longer mainly because of the volume of templates and content to review, not because the checks change.
When to get help
Some issues, such as rendering problems, large-scale duplication or migrations, need specialist experience. Our SEO team runs this audit, adds a full AI visibility review and turns the findings into a prioritised roadmap. Request a free audit to get started.