Email marketingDeliverability

The email deliverability checklist for growing brands

A practical email deliverability checklist: SPF, DKIM, DMARC, list hygiene, one-click unsubscribe and the sending habits that keep email out of spam.

By TRAGAUpdated

Blog cover for 'The email deliverability checklist for growing brands', white headline on an oxide red background beside a staircase of brand-coloured tiles

Short answer: to reach the inbox, authenticate your domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, send only to people who want your email, make unsubscribing easy and keep complaint rates low. Everything else is refinement.

Email deliverability is the difference between an email that was ‘delivered’ and one that was actually seen. Gmail and Yahoo tightened their requirements for bulk senders in February 2024, and other mailbox providers have moved the same way. If your clicks dropped without explanation, or a campaign that used to work suddenly does not, start with this checklist.

Why deliverability is a growing-brand problem

Small lists often get away with sloppy setups because volumes are low. As a brand grows, it adds tools, imports contacts from events and partners, sends more often and crosses the thresholds where mailbox providers apply stricter rules. Problems that were invisible at 2,000 subscribers become expensive at 50,000.

The fix is not a trick. It is a set of habits that prove to mailbox providers you are a legitimate sender whose email people want.

1. Authenticate your domain

  • SPF: a DNS record listing the services allowed to send as your domain. Include every tool that sends email for you, and stay under the 10 DNS lookup limit.
  • DKIM: a cryptographic signature that proves the message came from you and was not altered. Set up custom DKIM for each sending platform so it signs with your domain, not theirs.
  • DMARC: a policy that tells receivers what to do when SPF or DKIM fail, and sends you reports. Start with p=none, review the reports to find every legitimate sender, then move to quarantine and eventually reject.
  • Alignment: the domain in your visible From address should match the domain that passes SPF or DKIM. Without alignment, DMARC fails even when SPF and DKIM pass.

Google’s email sender guidelines and Yahoo’s sender best practices set out the exact requirements for bulk senders.

2. Send from a domain you control

Use your own domain, ideally a subdomain such as mail.yourbrand.com for marketing, so campaign reputation does not affect your team’s day-to-day email or your invoices and password resets. Never send marketing email from a free address like a Gmail account.

Keep transactional email, such as receipts and password resets, on a separate stream from marketing so a bad campaign never delays critical messages.

3. Make unsubscribing effortless

Include a visible unsubscribe link and support one-click unsubscribe headers, which Gmail and Yahoo now require for bulk marketing email. A person who cannot leave easily will press ‘report spam’ instead, which hurts far more. Process opt-outs within two days; the US CAN-SPAM rules allow 10 business days, but the mailbox provider rules are stricter.

A preference centre that lets people choose fewer emails or specific topics keeps some subscribers who would otherwise leave.

4. Keep your list clean

  • Use double opt-in for high-risk sources such as giveaways and event sign-ups.
  • Remove hard bounces immediately and suppress addresses that soft bounce repeatedly.
  • Suppress people who have not clicked or bought in a long time, after a short win-back attempt.
  • Never buy or rent lists. They are full of spam traps and people who never agreed to hear from you.

Good list hygiene often shrinks your list and improves your results at the same time.

5. Watch your complaint rate

Keep spam complaints well under 0.3 percent, and aim for under 0.1 percent. Google Postmaster Tools shows your rate for Gmail recipients for free, along with your domain reputation. Microsoft offers similar data through its Smart Network Data Services.

If complaints rise, look at what changed: a new list source, higher frequency or content that did not match what people signed up for. See our glossary entry on spam complaint rate for more detail.

6. Warm up new domains and IPs

Start with your most engaged subscribers and raise volume gradually over a few weeks. Sudden spikes look like spam. The same applies after a long break from sending or when you move to a new platform. Our email warm-up entry includes a typical schedule.

7. Send email people expect

Relevance is the best deliverability strategy. Segment your list so people receive content that matches their interests, send at a consistent rhythm and remind new subscribers why they are hearing from you. Engagement signals, such as replies, clicks and moving emails out of spam, all build reputation.

8. Write like a person

Clear subject lines that match the content, a real reply-to address, a balance of text and images, alt text on images and links to your own domain all help. Avoid link shorteners and misleading ‘Re:’ subject lines. Content matters less than reputation, but it still matters.

9. Monitor every week

Check bounce rate, complaint rate, unsubscribe rate and clicks for every campaign, plus Postmaster Tools and DMARC reports weekly. Remember that open rate is inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection, so rely on clicks and conversions to judge engagement.

A quick example

A growing skincare brand saw its Gmail inbox placement fall after importing 30,000 contacts from a partner promotion. Complaints jumped to 0.4 percent and its domain reputation dropped to ‘low’.

It paused sending to the imported contacts, set up custom DKIM and a DMARC monitoring policy, added one-click unsubscribe and sent only to subscribers who had clicked in the last 90 days for three weeks. Then it reintroduced the partner contacts slowly with a welcome email asking them to confirm. Reputation returned to ‘high’ within six weeks, and email revenue recovered to above its previous level.

When to get help

If you have done all of the above and still land in spam, the cause is usually reputation history or a misconfigured sending service. Our email marketing team can audit your authentication, list sources and sending patterns and fix what is holding you back. Start with a free audit.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Why are my emails suddenly going to spam?

The most common causes are missing or broken authentication, a spike in complaints or bounces, sending to an old or purchased list, or a sudden jump in volume. Check Google Postmaster Tools and your DMARC reports first.

Do I need DMARC if I only send a few emails?

Gmail and Yahoo require DMARC for bulk senders, but every domain benefits from it because it protects your brand from spoofing. A monitoring policy of p=none is a quick, safe start.

What complaint rate is too high?

Aim to stay below 0.1 percent and never reach 0.3 percent, which is the limit in Gmail and Yahoo's bulk sender requirements.

Should I use a dedicated IP address?

Only if you send high, consistent volumes, roughly hundreds of thousands of emails a month. Smaller senders usually do better on a reputable platform's shared IPs.

Free audit

Find out where you stand in search and AI answers.

Get a free audit of your SEO, AI visibility and email setup. We send a short, specific report with the three changes that would move the needle most.